Stan my not so favourite man
Monday, February 1st, 2010




Now to be fair I wasn’t a big fan of him on Idol, to be honest I wasn’t a big fan of anyone on the latest Australian Idol. I thought they were all a bit low rent, not that my opinion counts when it comes to singing. They would have to be tone deaf for me to make it past the first audition. But seriously we all have seen enough of these shows to become Simon Cowell stand-ins. I did think at the time, is this the best that Australia has to offer?
So it really hasn’t come as a big surprise that the CD has turned out to be a big fizzer for me.
I have to say Purple Rain has always been a song I loved even if I hadn’t heard it for years, but the real kicker would have to be one of my all time favourite songs was ‘Hallelujah’ sung by Lenoard Cohen. Now there are some things that just shouldn’t be touched, to say he killed these songs would be being nice. He damn well murdered it. He starts off so low, to low for him and its hard to decipher the words, it gets better as he goes on but really not much.
The girls initially thought that I was being unkind until they heard him sing the ‘Climb’ song which Miley Cirus has on her latest album. Whilst she may have been marketed to death, she can at least sing and has quite a distinctive voice. So once again why try to rerecord a song that she sings and is really popular. Ugh I know he sung these songs on Idol but that doesn’t necessarily make them great choices for an album.
The only positive on the CD has to be his song ‘Black Box’, this I do concede is sung well and suits him. Don’t get me wrong I am all for people triumphing over adversity which he clearly has and should be proud of that. But I have really been disappointed with the album and am surprised the so-called experts advising him have released this rubbish. Stan can sing but it just shouldn’t be some of these songs.
Available: all leading record stores, The Warehouse Price: $34.95 (pricing varies)
Track Listing:
1. Purple Rain
2. The Climb
3. Man’s World
4. Ordinary People
5. Let’s Stay Together
6. Hallelujah
7. Superstar
8. We Will Rock You
9. Think Of Me
10. Black Box